Tag Archives: La Traviata

Review: La Traviata, Venue Cymru, Llandudno by Richard Evans

A Senbla production of an Ellen Kent Opera featuring the Opera International, Kyiv, Ukraine.

 out of 5 stars (4 / 5)

On tour nationwide until April

La Traviata, a tale of forbidden love and loss with some hauntingly beautiful melodies.  Can a man from a well to do background fall in love with a fallen woman and find acceptance from his family no matter how rich she is?

Ellen Kent’s La Traviata followed a pattern established over recent years.  The set was simple, an intricate backdrop that stayed the same for each act, with little, yet effective scenery and an orchestra that played subtly.  In effect this drew attention strongly to the stage, the costuming, voices and the acting.  As a visual spectacle this show was pleasing to the eye, the costumes suitably opulent and the background evocative of a grand ballroom.   The voices were superb but movement on stage was often more pedestrian than animated.  

The story, based on a play, the Lady of the Camellias by Alexandre Dumas is a tragedy.  Violetta is dying but when she meets a gentleman, Alfredo, they fall passionately in love.  His father persuades Violetta to abandon Alfredo to preserve the family’s honour and protect the reputation of a younger sister.  However, once Violetta is nearing her end, she is reconciled with Alfredo and the father shows some remorse for causing their rift.

The storyline dictates that the spotlight is very firmly on the soloists and in particular the lead soprano, Violetta, played by Viktoriia Melnyk.  Her voice was rich, powerful and striking especially when hitting the top notes.  Her duets with Alfredo, played by Hovhannes Andreasyan in Act 1 and with Alfredo’s father, sang by Iurie Gisca in Act 2 are heart warmingly memorable.  The large company support the leads well although more could be made of some scenes for example when the Baron challenges Alfredo to a duel.  I expected to see much more anger from the Baron.

By modern standards, there are some weaknesses to the plot.  The father, despite being told that Violetta is dying asks her to make a huge sacrifice stating that Alfredo will fall out of love with her when her looks disappear in the future.  Hardly the most understanding attitude to someone in the last throes of tuberculosis.  However, like any story it is a child of its time and attitudes have changed.  Of course women today have more personal freedom and their success in life is not defined by achieving a good match.  Society is also not as condemnatory towards people with a so called illicit lifestyle.  No matter how good a person Violetta was, she could never achieve respectability because she was a courtesan.

This production of La Triaviata is part of the farewell tour for Ellen Kents opera company.  It is accompanied by Carmen, also showing at Venue Cymru, and Madame Butterfly.  Over the past 30 years, Ellen Kent Opera and Ballet International has established a reputation for producing high quality opera and opening up the genre to a wider audience.  La Traviata is a classic opera that lives long in the memory and is therefore a fitting part of this farewell tour and leads to a sense of expectation for the next instalment, Carmen.    

La Traviata – a review by Eva Marloes

Stacey Alleaume as Violetta in La Traviata, photo by Julian Guidera

 out of 5 stars (3.5 / 5)

In the past week, the documentary In Plain Sight, an investigation by Channel 4’s Dispatches and the Sunday Times, has alleged that comedian turned wellness guru Russell Brand is responsible for exploitative treatment of women, including rape and sexual assault. Just like when the #MeToo  movement emerged, many have questioned the women speaking out. Women are still exploited by powerful men and their sexuality is still policed.

La Traviata couldn’t be more topical. Verdi’s opera was shocking in depicting and taking the side of a ‘fallen woman’, what today might be an escort. Alas, the unimaginative direction, originally by Sir David McVicar, here by Sarah Crisp, makes it look preposterous and bizarre.

Violetta, a courtesan, meets Alfredo at a lavish party. She decides to leave that life and live with Alfredo supporting their life together financially. Unbeknown to Alfredo, his father asks Violetta to leave his son to protect his and his family’s reputation. 

Stacey Alleaume as Violetta and Mark S Ross as Giorgio Germont in La Traviata, photo by Julian Guidera

Violetta leaves Alfredo who feels spurned and acts his revenge by throwing money at her in public to repay her. Verdi thinks she has a dignity and should be respected.

It is none other than Alfredo’s father who defends her and condemns his own son for disrespecting her. Yet, only at the very end Alfredo learns that Violetta sacrificed their love and life together for his reputation. He comes back to see her dying. 

La Traviata could still be a powerful story if set in today’s times, just as James Macdonald’s clever production of Rigoletto did by setting it in Washington DC in the #MeToo era. 

The WNO’s traditional setting fails to convey Verdi’s intention. The choice of a very dark set design, presumably to symbolise impending doom, has a jarring effect on the opening scene whose frivolity and joviality are dampened. It weakens the unfolding of the tragedy and frustrates the solid performances of the artists. 

David Junghoon Kim shines as Alfredo, just as he did as the Duke in Rigoletto. He is at home with Verdi and gives a performance full of pathos. His beautiful tonality and powerful voice deliver longing and sorrow effectively. Stacey Alleaume as Violetta has a splendid coloratura. She’s at ease on high notes and bel canto. In the ‘croce e delizia’ duet with Alfredo in Act I, she seemed often overpowered by David Junghoon Kim when singing at a lower range. She is stronger in the second act with Mark S Ross, playing Alfredo’s father Giorgio Germont, and the final dying scene. Mark S Ross has a beautiful baritone voice. He gives an excellent performance.

The WNO’s chorus is strong as ever. The orchestra, under the baton of Alexander Joel, gives a solid, albeit uninspiring, performance.

David Junghoon Kim and Stacey Alleaume in La Traviata, photo by Julian Guidera.

Review La Traviata, WNO, Wales Millennium Centre, Cardiff BY Barbara Michaels

 

 out of 5 stars (4 / 5)

 

After the epic production of War and Peace, which opened Welsh National Opera’s 2018 autumn season, the ever-popular La Traviata – Verdi’s most performed and well-loved opera – comes as something of a relief. The fact that this is a second time round revival of WNO’s original co-production with Scottish Opera in 2009, with a more recent revival just four years ago, proves the point.

Basically a love story, with the doomed love of Parisian courtesan Violetta for the young bourgeois Alfredo Germont centre stage, the themes – thwarted love, duty and tragic death– are still relevant today, as they were back in the mid-nineteenth century, when the opera received its first performance in Venice. Wisely, McVicar has chosen to keep to the traditional, with a sumptuous period setting whose opulence fairly reeks of decadence, represented in voluminous black drapes sweeping across the stage at opportune moments. This effective device works well– unfortunately the same cannot be said of the onstage activity inserted before the overture.

With twos sopranos, both of whom are experiencded in the role, singing the role of Violetta on different dates sprinkled throughout the run, David Poultney, in his final year as artistic director of WNO, could hardly lose. Making her debut on the Donald Gordon stage at the Millennium, Armenian singer Anush Hovhannisyan, who previously sang the role with Scottish Opera, proved once again what a fine voice she has. Her pure soprano, coupled with her acting ability, makes her an ideal choice for the role – heart-wringing in the final scenes. Opposite her, as Violetta’s lover Alfredo Germont,.Australian-Chinese tenor Kang Wang, has a strong voice and, while needing to display a stronger persona in scene two of Act II, nevertheless shows empathy with the role, coming into his own in the tragic ending and in his duets with Hovhannisyan throughout. .Interestingly, both these singers represented their respective countries in the 2017 BBC Cardiff Singer of the World competition in which Wang reached the main prize final.

Roland Woods’ sonorous baritone lends gravitas to the role of Germont pater, while Rebecca Afonwy-Jones, who hales from mid-Wales, is appropriately lively as the party girl Flora. Conductor James Southall’s interpretation of Verdi’s wonderful score is magnificent, as is the choreographing of the masquerade,by Andrew George and revival choreographer Colm Seery with some wonderful jumps and grands jetės executed superbly by the dancers.

An opportunity for the always reliable WNO chorus to shine and for the ladies to enjoy wearing the elegant gowns of the era, with their low cut bodices and the bustles favoured at that time, although the latter was a somewhat over-generous embellishment to Violetta’s gown in Act I , while in the second half the trousers of Alfredo’s suit appear over-long. Minor details – but why not get them right?

Overall, though, a revival that has stood the test of time.

Run: Various dates throughout October and November, ending November 23rd.

Music: Giuseppe Verdi

Libretto: Francesco Maria Piave

Director: David McVicar

Revival Director: Sarah Crisp

Artistic Director: David Poultney

Reviewer: Barbara Michaels