The fourth ‘Breaking out of the Box’ symposium- a series of events to discuss the issue of diversity in Welsh Arts, took place at Theatre Clwyd on 16th February. Subtitled ‘Wales: a Diverse Nation?’ An access symposium’ the focus of the event centered on the question of how diverse are we, and what can we do to change things?
Opening the event was Nick Capaldi, Chief Executive, Arts Council Wales. He spoke about the history of the Arts Council and Diversity- citing reports from as far back as the 90s into the issue. He acknowledged the responsibility as a publicly funded organisation towards diversity:
"As publicly funded organisations we must be places of empathy, inclusion, community engagement, discussion as well as being sources of imaginative delight." Nick Capaldi @Arts_Wales_ #DiverseWales
— Hynt (@we_are_hynt) February 16, 2018
Capaldi also noted the need to do more to reach communities and the idea of ‘changing hearts and minds’. While this contribution from Arts Council Wales was welcome, and well intended it was let down by a lack of representation from the organisation throughout the day. The focus of the day around galvanising towards action, having an engaged representatives from the Development teams at ACW could really have helped the organisations present to make practical steps in their next projects towards diversity. We all know ACW funding is at the heart of the work made in Wales, and a level of practical support and real engagement on the day from the organisation would have made a huge difference to what could have been achieved. While Capaldi’s support was welcome, and his words supportive, it felt like a missed opportunity from ACW.
Following Capaldi, my own talk. Which focused on turning questions back on the audience to reflect on for the day.
"Our lack of diversity not being helped by a narrow focus. We can learn by examples, we can only do that by discussing it." @EmiGarside #DiverseWales
— Hynt (@we_are_hynt) February 16, 2018
Reflecting on the discussions already taking place, a call to keep talking and keep fighting through these issues
"It's great that we're fighting about it on Facebook and twitter. We need to keep pushing and pushing." @EmiGarside #DiverseWales
— Hynt (@we_are_hynt) February 16, 2018
As hoped this provocation moved into an engaged discussion about the many areas that need addressing- from programming to the access needs of audiences.
@takingflightco #diversewales
Absolutely wonderful things happening @ClwydTweets today #access #allequal pic.twitter.com/Jd0Wkx8Bzj— ǝuᴉuɐſ 🏴 🇪🇺🤝 (@juxtaposed13) February 16, 2018
Following a break we heard from Jamie Beddard, one of the UK’s leading disabled theatre practitioners, Jamie talked through his experiences as a disabled performer.
"Disability is part of a nuanced identity. It is not the overriding characteristic." @Jamiebed #DiverseWales #diversewales pic.twitter.com/xvUlqRFQ4n
— Hynt (@we_are_hynt) February 16, 2018
Jamie’s experiences, and the video clips he showed of projects in England he’s been a part of showed that the sky literally is the limit for what can be achieved.
Jamie was part of a couple of amazing circus projects where disabled performers worked alongside able bodied performers with no barriers or prejudice around what they were or weren’t expected to do. That this kind of work is possible can be an example for companies in Wales to aspire to.
Keen for the day to have some practical take-aways there were two workshops on accessibility led by Elise and Beth from Taking Flight Theatre Company. Elise took people through some simple steps to make a rehearsal room more inclusive, while Beth talked through making accessible marketing materials.
Accessible marketing materials workshop with the brilliant Beth from @takingflightco #DiverseWales pic.twitter.com/67OBv5JzV6
— Hynt (@we_are_hynt) February 16, 2018
These practical elements were a really useful element of the day for the group-providing some tangible next steps that are relatively easy to incorporate and help slowly change the nature of diversity and accessibility.
Finally, the last two provocations of the day. Michele Taylor, Director for Change for Ramps on the Moon and critic Jafar Iqbal. Both proved to be a rousing call to action. Michele punctuated their talk with the repeated phrase ‘Seriously are we still talking about this?’ Sharing her frustration but also experience in creating active solutions through ‘Ramps on the Moon’ this was a non-nonsense call to get things done. And one which also called out well meaning sentiment with again, a call to concrete action.
Don’t describe something as “accessible” give people the specifics so they feel comfortable in your venue. #DiverseWales
— Dr Emily Garside (@EmiGarside) February 16, 2018
"Be rigorous about the Social Model. It's non-negotiable." Michele Taylor, Director for Change from @RampsOTM #DiverseWales
— Hynt (@we_are_hynt) February 16, 2018
Challenging all of us on everything from our choice of language to what we believe to be exclusivity Michele provoked passionate discussion about how we really enact change. There was also a clear desire from the room to mimic the ‘Ramps on the Moon’ initiative in Wales.
Finally Jafar Iqbal talked about the lack of change we’re experiencing in Wales. Criticizing those at the top for a lack of action while others repeatedly shout for change.
Progress is frighteningly slow because the people whose job it is to listen aren’t @writeofcentre #DiverseWales
— Dr Emily Garside (@EmiGarside) February 16, 2018
Drawing on his own experience as a British Asian, Iqbal has often wondered if he’s in a room to ‘tick a box’ but is also conscious that he’s benefited from that in his career. And despite personally benefiting, being conscious that this approach isn’t good enough any more.
"I had a dilemma. I was going to start saying "I'm honoured and privileged" when actually I'm not. It's 2018. In Wales. We've not done enough to sort it out." @writeofcentre #DiverseWales
"We should be miles ahead of where we are now."
— Hynt (@we_are_hynt) February 16, 2018
Acknowledging the recent controversies in Wales, Iqbal talked about the need to change being felt across the sector, but a lack of action being taken. And actually giving us a fairly simple way to start solving these issues:
“We need to shut the fuck up and listen” @writeofcentre ends the provocations on a clear note #DiverseWales
— Dr Emily Garside (@EmiGarside) February 16, 2018
Further discussion in the room, following this final clear provocation was to that end- the time for talking (and social media debate) has passed and it’s time for action. The very clear notion however, was that this needs leadership. And that is something the movement for diversity in Wales is lacking. Not from those engaged in the arts, but from those organisations with the power and scope to be really influential in making change. And this remains a frustration.
Despite continued frustrations, it was a galvanizing and productive event. Connections between organisations developed during discussion and networking time and there seemed a real commitment to move forward from the event with a new sense of purpose.
Let’s hope that soon an event won’t be asking the question of Diversity in Wales but simply celebrating it instead.
The event was organised by Hynt, Creu Cymru and Taking Flight Theatre with support from Arts Council Wales.
More information about Ramps on the Moon and the work they have done to date can be found on their website.
Emily Garside