An orchestra must play as an act of defiance. Few would deny this upon seeing the Ukrainian Freedom Orchestra after their invasion from Russa back in 2022. The Songs for Ukraine Chorus are also made up one hundred and sixty singers, of those effected by the conflict. Prior to this all consuming concert at St Paul’s, a few speakers told of the importance of these musicians. Most telling, was General Valeriy Zaluzhny, UK Ambassador to Ukraine, who spoke of the utmost urgency of the events occurring in their home country. Having also followed other conflicts since, it really hit me hard just how impactful this has been to the world.
A fine opening with Bucha, Lacrimosa by Victoria Vita Polevá, which detailed the massacre Russia commit in spring of the year of invasion. With violinist Marko Komonko, this was deeply impactful…I was lost in the emotion the whole thing. Not dissimilar to Arvo Pärt and John Tavener, a feeling of the sacred minimalist took over the massive space. Terrifying metallic percussion stood out and possible electronics were a softer fiber in the overall orchestration. Komonko played stupendously. A gentle handling of the strings and their harmonics was another compelling element. Polevá took a bow at the end and proves she is a composer to watch out for.
Two hundred years have passed since the advent of Beethoven’s 9th Symphony, sometimes dubbed the ‘Choral’. Often used as a marker during times of conflict, this was particularly hefty with these players. Conductor Keri-Lynn Wilson graciously led all through the epic piece: its primordial opening, melodic pixelations, piercing melodic bite and earthy ruminations. The acoustics of the cathedral did frequently blur the focus, yet other times its vapours were highly rewarding. I’d say the last three movement had passages were the sound worked but other bars were like mush. We can leave that aside thanks to the context of the evening.
Also sung in Ukrainian, adding extra layers and personal touches. The four soloists Olga Bezsmertna, Natalia Kukhar, Valentyn Dytiuk and Andrii Kymach wowed with their respective sung momentum. Kymach in his baritone, may have been at the mercy of acoustics, though often delighted with a burr, you’d expect from the range. Olga Bezsmertna had a frequent smile on her face, lost in the music, soaring notes she fared very well in and constantly engaged with the audience. Natalia Kukhar as mezzo added to the pot, her time with Olga some sweet, touching remembrances. Tenor Valentyn Dytiuk, got a famous, cheery solo with an almost ommpa band styling, towards the end, a voice that you want to hear again. Of course, the recognisable Ode to Joy, left me highly moved and this crowd loved what they heard. The lady sat behind me also remarked about the acoustic, though stated the concert was “symbolic”.
An encore by Yuri Shevchenko: WE DO EXIST! was a paraphrase to the melody by M. Verbytskyi (National Anthem of Ukraine) for violin and strings. All stood for what we assumed was a more traditional take in the anthem, though this version was eerie and chilling. A concert for the history books.
To place such large forces under the dome of St Paul’s Cathedral was careless. Did no one involved in in the planning know about acoustics? The resulting mush was impossible to assess for quality. This has to be viewed as a political not a cultural event, and should have been marketed as such. “An evening of Ukrainian patriotism, with something reminiscent of Beethoven “.